Aquarium, Blog, Maintenance

Choosing the Right Aquarium Filter

Choosing the Right Aquarium Filter, a photo of a black and white fish tank with a filter

Table of Contents

Are there Different Types of Aquarium Filters?

The right aquarium filter is a crucial part of keeping your tank healthy, thriving, and clean. Filters primarily help remove debris and waste, ensuring that your fish and plants have a clean environment. They also provide a place for healthy bacteria to grow, which helps break down harmful chemicals like ammonia, produced from waste and uneaten food. Without a good filter and filter media, these chemicals can quickly become lethal to your fish. This blog outlines the main types of aquarium filters you’ll encounter and what makes each one beneficial.

1. Hang-On-Back Filters

Hang-On-Back (HOB) filters are among the most popular choices for aquarium owners. They’re affordable, easy to use, and versatile. These filters hang on the back of your tank and use a siphon tube to draw water into the filter, where it passes through different types of media before returning to the tank.

Pros and Cons of a Hang-On-Back Filter

Pros:
  • Ease of Installation: HOB filters are very easy to set up.
  • Affordability: Compared to canister filters, HOB filters are typically among the most affordable.
  • Effective Filtration: HOB filters usually provide good mechanical, chemical, and biological filtration.
  • Accessibility: Since HOB filters are external, they’re easy to access for maintenance.
Cons:
  • Noise: HOB filters can be noisy, especially the water pouring back into the tank.
  • Visible Equipment: HOB filters are mounted on the back of the tank and can be visible, which might detract from your aquarium’s aesthetic appeal.
  • Flow Rate Issues: Some models have a strong flow rate that can be difficult to adjust.
  • Space: HOB filters require the tank to be positioned a few inches away from the wall.

A Few Good Options for Hang-On-Back Filters

Price Range: $20 – $70

HOB filters are my top recommendation for beginners, with sponge filters being a close second. They’re simple to set up and maintain, making them a great option for those new to the hobby. However, if you need a quiet environment, HOB filters can be a bit noisy.

2. Canister Filters

Canister filters are ideal for larger or heavily stocked tanks. These external filters sit beneath your tank with tubes that pump water through a canister filled with filter media, offering powerful filtration and high flow rates.

Pros and Cons of a Canister Filter

Pros:
  • Superior Filtration: Canister filters offer tremendous filtration capabilities.
  • Customizable Filter Media: The large canister allows for customizable filtration media.
  • Quiet Operation: Canister filters are often quieter since they can be hidden away.
  • High Flow Rate: Canister filters typically have adjustable high flow rates.
  • Durable and Long-Lasting: Canister filters are generally more durable than HOB filters.
Cons:
  • Higher Cost: Canister filters are more expensive compared to other options.
  • Complex Installation: Setting up a canister filter requires more steps than other types.
  • Maintenance Challenges: Canister filters can be difficult to maintain.
  • Potential for Leaks: Canister filters may develop leaks if not properly maintained.

A Few Good Options for Canister Filters

Price Range: $50 – $200

If you have a large or heavily stocked tank, canister filters are the best option. They provide powerful and customizable filtration, though they do require a significant investment and regular maintenance.

3. Sponge Filters

Sponge filters are my go-to for breeding tanks. They provide gentle filtration and a large surface area for beneficial bacteria, making them ideal for small fry and delicate species.

Pros and Cons of Sponge Filters

Pros:
  • Gentle Filtration: Sponge filters have a gentle water flow, safe for small or delicate species.
  • Promotes Beneficial Bacteria: The large surface area encourages beneficial bacterial growth.
  • Easy to Maintain: Simply squeeze the sponge in tank water to clean it.
  • Affordable: Sponge filters are inexpensive.
  • Oxygenation: Air-driven sponge filters also help oxygenate the water.
Cons:
  • Limited Mechanical Filtration: Sponge filters lack chemical filtration capabilities.
  • Not Suitable for Large Tanks: Sponge filters may struggle in tanks larger than 20 gallons.
  • Visual Impact: Sponge filters can be visually unappealing.
  • Requires Additional Equipment: An air pump is required to operate sponge filters.

A Few Good Options for Sponge Filters

Price Range: $5 – $20

For breeding or shrimp tanks, sponge filters are unbeatable. They provide gentle, calm filtration that won’t harm baby fry or shrimp. However, for larger tanks, you might need additional filtration.

4. Internal Filters

Internal filters are placed inside the tank and are a compact solution for small to medium-sized aquariums. They’re easy to install and provide effective filtration, especially in smaller spaces.

Pros and Cons of Internal Filters

Pros:
  • Compact Design: Internal filters have a small footprint, with only the power cord outside the tank.
  • Easy Installation: These filters are easy to install with suction cups or brackets.
  • Quiet Operation: Being submerged, internal filters are usually quiet.
  • Affordable: Internal filters are generally affordable, similar in price to HOB filters.
  • Versatility: Many internal filters offer adjustable flow rates.
Cons:
  • Limited Filtration Capacity: Internal filters typically have limited filtration capacity due to their small size.
  • Maintenance Challenges: Cleaning an internal filter can be messy and inconvenient.
  • Tank Space & Appearance: Internal filters take up space inside the tank and are visible.
  • Heat Transfer: Some internal filters can produce heat, which may affect the water temperature in smaller tanks.

A Few Good Options for Internal Filters

Price Range: $10 – $50

Internal filters are a great choice for small to medium tanks, especially if you have limited space or want a quieter environment. They’re easy to install, making them a good choice for beginners.

5. Undergravel Filters

Undergravel filters are a decent option for tanks using coarse gravel. They’re installed at the bottom of the tank, with the substrate placed on top, providing basic filtration. However, they’re not ideal for heavily stocked or large tanks.

Pros and Cons of Undergravel Filters

Pros:
  • Cost-Effective: Undergravel filters are generally inexpensive.
  • Simple Design: With no moving parts, undergravel filters have few chances of mechanical failure.
  • Minimal Visual Impact: These filters are hidden beneath the substrate.
  • Low Maintenance: Once set up, undergravel filters require minimal maintenance.
Cons:
  • Limited Mechanical Filtration: Undergravel filters offer very basic filtration.
  • Potential for Clogging: Over time, the substrate can become clogged with debris, reducing efficiency.
  • Unsuitable for Planted Tanks: The constant water flow can disrupt plant roots.
  • Challenging to Modify or Clean: Accessing undergravel filters for maintenance is difficult.
  • Not Ideal for Large Bioloads: Undergravel filters are not designed for heavily stocked tanks.

A Few Good Options for Undergravel Filters

Price Range: $10 – $30

Undergravel filters are a budget-friendly option, particularly for lightly stocked tanks. However, other filters typically offer better performance and are easier to maintain.

Which Filter is Best for Your Tank Size and Fish?

The best filter for your tank depends largely on its size and the type of fish you keep. Here are a few considerations to help you decide:

Small Tanks (Up to 20 Gallons)

For small tanks, an internal or sponge filter is recommended. These filters provide adequate filtration without taking up too much space. For a small community tank, an internal filter works well. For breeding or shrimp tanks, a sponge filter is ideal, though keep in mind that internal filters may affect water temperature.

Medium Tanks (20 to 55 Gallons)

For medium-sized tanks, a Hang-On-Back or canister filter is recommended. HOB filters are easy to maintain and can handle most setups. However, if your tank is heavily stocked, a canister filter would be the better choice.

Large Tanks (55 Gallons and Above)

For large tanks, a canister filter is the best option. It offers the most powerful filtration necessary to maintain water quality in large, heavily stocked tanks. Though more expensive, the investment is worth it for the long-term health of your aquarium.

Conclusion

Choosing the right aquarium filter is essential for maintaining a healthy environment for your fish. By understanding the different types of filters, their pros and cons, and price ranges, you can make an informed decision that best suits your tank’s needs. Whether you’re setting up a new aquarium or upgrading your current setup, the right filter can make all the difference! Feel free to leave a comment or ask questions if you have any!

Leave a Reply